Most eCom brands run blanket 20% off promotions on Google Shopping during peak periods. The numbers show exactly why that destroys net margin. Offering shopping promotions on high-intent search terms merely subsidises buyers who were already determined to checkout at full retail price. Constant best-seller discounting is an unforced margin leak masquerading as high return on ad spend.
We audited 47 Google Ads accounts last quarter. The exact same mistake showed up in 41 of them. Brands push their Merchant centre promotions across their entire Shopify product feed. They see top-line revenue spike. They assume the discount worked. It did not. You just paid a 20% premium to acquire customers you already had.
I built Gearbunch to 8 figures by protecting margin on hero products. I see too many founders giving that margin away to Google. Stop doing this. It is killing your profitability.
The margin fallacy of Google Shopping promotions on core products
Let us look at how conversion volume lies to you. When you apply a promotional tag to your best-sellers in Google Merchant centre, conversion rates naturally lift. Your ROAS looks incredible on paper.
But best-seller conversion volume gives a false signal of promotional incrementality. Incrementality measures the sales you would not have made without the discount. For your core products, that number is often zero.
Think about the economic cost of subsidising high-intent customers. A